Home

What size water heater do I need?

By Roof & Router Team. Updated October 17, 2026.

Short answer: Homes of two to four people typically need a 40- to 50-gallon tank water heater, and a family of four usually needs about 50 gallons, per A.O. Smith and Rheem sizing guides. The U.S. Department of Energy says to size by first hour rating (FHR) instead of tank size. Add up the hot water your household uses in its busiest hour, about 20 gallons per shower, and choose a heater whose FHR is at least that number.

Skip to what to buy (5 types) ↓

What size water heater do you need?

For a standard tank water heater, manufacturer charts give these starting points:

Household A.O. Smith Rheem (gas water heaters)
1 to 2 people 30 to 40 gallons 30 to 40 gallons
3 people 40 to 50 gallons 40 to 50 gallons (2 to 4 people)
4 people 50 to 75 gallons 50 to 55 gallons (4 to 5 people)
5 people 75 to 100 gallons 75 gallons or tankless (5+ people)

So a family of four usually lands around 50 gallons. A.O. Smith says 50 gallons is “a comfortable fit, but it depends on habits.” Both companies treat these charts as rough guides. A.O. Smith calls its chart an approximate guide and recommends estimating your peak demand instead. Rheem publishes a second chart on another page that runs much larger (50 to 60 gallons even for one or two people), which shows how loose the rules of thumb are.

A better method is the one the U.S. Department of Energy recommends: size by first hour rating.

Why first hour rating matters more than tank size

The first hour rating (FHR) is “the number of gallons of hot water the heater can supply per hour,” starting with a full tank, according to DOE. It combines the water stored in the tank with how fast the burner or element reheats new water.

That is why two 50-gallon tanks can deliver different amounts. Rheem notes that burner size and efficiency change the FHR of same-size tanks.

Where to find it: DOE says the EnergyGuide label (the yellow label) lists it in the top left corner as “Capacity (first hour rating).” Federal label rules sort water heaters into FHR bins:

Label category First hour rating
Very small under 18 gallons
Low 18 to 50.9 gallons
Medium 51 to 74.9 gallons
High 75 gallons and up

How to calculate your peak-hour demand

DOE’s method has three steps.

Step 1. Pick the hour of the day when your household uses the most hot water. For most families it is the morning rush.

Step 2. Add up the hot water used in that hour, with DOE’s average figures:

Activity Gallons of hot water per use
Shower 20
Shaving 2
Hand dishwashing or food prep 3
Automatic dishwasher 7
Clothes washer, top-loading 25
Clothes washer, front-loading 15

Step 3. Choose a water heater with a first hour rating at least as high as that total. A.O. Smith says the same or slightly larger.

DOE’s example: 3 showers (60) + 1 shave (2) + hand dishwashing (3) = 66 gallons, so you need an FHR of 66 gallons or more.

A family of four, our math: 4 morning showers (80) + breakfast dishes by hand (3) = 83 gallons. That calls for an FHR in the “High” category, 75 gallons or more. If one shower moves to the evening, the peak drops to 63 gallons and a smaller heater could work.

DOE’s 20 gallons per shower is an average, so homes with short showers or low-flow showerheads may need less.

Gas vs. electric: does the fuel change the size?

Yes, because gas heats water faster. A.O. Smith says:

So an electric heater often needs a bigger tank to reach the same first hour rating as a gas one. Always compare FHRs, not just gallons. For the reheat math by tank size and season, see how long it takes a water heater to heat up.

What size heat pump water heater do you need?

Heat pump water heaters move heat from the surrounding air into the water. They use much less electricity but heat water more slowly.

Federal rules are pushing electric tanks toward heat pumps. A DOE rule published in May 2024 takes effect May 6, 2029. A.O. Smith says it will require heat pump technology for electric tanks over 35 gallons (up to 120). Gas tanks of 20 to 55 gallons get only a modest efficiency increase, and atmospheric-vent gas models will need a damper. As of October 2026, DOE’s rulemaking page still lists the 2024 rule. Check before you buy, since rules can change.

What size tankless water heater do you need?

Tankless heaters are sized by flow rate (gallons per minute) instead of gallons stored. DOE’s method:

  1. Add up the flow rates of everything that might run at once. DOE’s example: a 2.5 gpm shower plus a 0.75 gpm faucet = 3.25 gpm.
  2. Work out the temperature rise. DOE says to assume 50°F incoming water unless you know otherwise, and 120°F hot water, a 70°F rise. Rheem’s rule of thumb is that winter incoming water is about 40°F in the northern tier of states, so the rise there is closer to 80°F (our math).
  3. Choose a unit rated for your flow at that rise. DOE says gas units typically deliver about 5 gpm at a 70°F rise and electric units about 2 gpm.

By our math, a typical electric tankless unit (about 2 gpm at a 70°F rise) may not keep up with two 2.5 gpm showers at once, especially in a cold climate. DOE notes that even the largest gas-fired tankless model can’t supply enough hot water for many simultaneous uses in large households. For the full comparison, see tankless vs. tank water heaters.

How much hot water does a household use a day?

DOE’s FEMP buying guide lists daily hot water use of about 10, 38, 55 and 84 gallons for its very small, low, medium and high usage categories, with 55 gallons a day as medium use. DOE also says tankless heaters are 24 to 34% more efficient than tanks in homes that use 41 gallons or less a day, and 8 to 14% more efficient in homes that use around 86 gallons a day.

Get more from the size you have

What to buy

The main types, who each one suits, and what to check before you buy. Each link opens matching products at that store.

  1. Electric tank water heater, 50 gallon

    Best for: a typical 3- to 4-person home on electric service.

    Look for: a first hour rating that covers your peak hour, and the UEF on the EnergyGuide label.

  2. Gas tank water heater, 40-50 gallon

    Best for: homes with gas that want faster recovery from the same size tank.

    Look for: first hour rating, venting type that matches your home, and UEF.

  3. ENERGY STAR heat pump water heater

    Best for: cutting water heating costs in a basement or garage with room around the unit.

    Look for: ENERGY STAR certification, first hour rating, and the space and temperature limits in the manual.

  4. Low-flow showerhead

    Best for: stretching the hot water you have, so the same tank covers more showers.

    Look for: a WaterSense label and a low rated flow (gpm) printed on the package.

  5. Digital thermometer

    Best for: checking that your tap water is at about 120°F after installing a new heater.

    Look for: a probe or instant-read thermometer that reads above 140°F.

These links open search results at Amazon, Walmart, The Home Depot, Lowe's and Best Buy. We do not earn anything from them, and no brand paid to be listed.

Quick answers

What size water heater do I need for a family of 4?
Usually about 50 gallons. A.O. Smith calls 50 gallons a comfortable fit for four and lists 50 to 75 gallons for four people. Check that the first hour rating covers your busiest hour, which can be 80 gallons or more if four people shower in the morning.
Is a 40-gallon water heater enough for 2 people?
Usually yes. A.O. Smith says 40 gallons works well for one to two people with average use, and Rheem lists 30 to 40 gallons for one or two people.
What is a first hour rating on a water heater?
It is how many gallons of hot water the heater can deliver in one hour starting with a full tank. DOE says it is the number to size by, and it appears in the top left corner of the yellow EnergyGuide label.
How many showers can a 50-gallon water heater handle?
It depends on its first hour rating and your showerheads. Using DOE's figure of about 20 gallons per shower, a heater with an FHR of 80 gallons covers about four showers in an hour, our math.
Do gas water heaters recover faster than electric?
Yes. A.O. Smith says most gas models reheat a full tank in 30 to 40 minutes, while electric tanks need 60 to 90 minutes. That generally gives a gas tank a higher first hour rating than an electric tank of the same size, so compare the labels.
Should I get a bigger tank with a heat pump water heater?
Often yes. Rheem recommends going up a tank size because heat pump models heat water more slowly, and ENERGY STAR says to start from your current tank size and go larger if you are adding people or fixtures.
What size tankless water heater do I need?
Add up the flow rates of fixtures that run at the same time, and check the rating at your temperature rise. DOE's example is a 2.5 gpm shower plus a 0.75 gpm faucet, which needs at least 3.25 gpm.

Sources